Getting Things Done Rematch, Round 2: Software
I have determined that I need to use software to manage my projects. As mentioned in a previous post, the 105 GTD Software Apps comparison page is a pretty handy resource. At last it’s broken out by OS, so it beats the other lists I’ve seen. My investigation is specific to GTD apps on the Mac. It is also relevant to note that I’m running Leopard 10.5.2. Now let’s get to it.
Check Off
Ok, this was my original solution, and I was really fond of its simplicity. It turns out, however, that it is simply TOO simple. I need a little more. Ciao!
Chandler
Holy crap is this confusing. Maybe I’ll come back to it later when everything sucks, but for now… Pass!
Shadow Plan
Call me shallow, but the website is so inelegant that I’m betting the software is as well. I didn’t bother to download it.
Frictionless
This one seems far more promising. The website isn’t amazing, but it’s quite clear in how it’s laid out. Best of all, the developer seems seriously committed to the project. I’ll skip the few details I have on the setup process, and cut straight to the worst of all. Worst of all, it crashed on me. Twice. One of the times, I was simply removing the “work” context from the context list. Unacceptable. Sayonara.
iGTD
This one easily has the best website of those listed so far. But holy cow is it complicated. It was actually the first thing I installed today, but I just gave up and went for something simpler. Also, I got it to crash a couple of times, though I forget what I was doing to cause it. Oh, I know, I imported the text data from Check Off, and was promoting one of the tasks to a project. Apparently, that was a bad idea. Three times in a row. That’s why I gave up on it. I’ll go back to it and see how things go. Now if it’s crashing on manipulating the data from another program, well, that could be acceptable, as it isn’t a part of normal functionality for me. And there’s not enough stuff in Check Off that I can’t just retype it.
Anyway, the interface is the prettiest of the batch so far. I want to like it and use it, if that counts for anything.
Ok, wtf. Neverming. I CANNOT ADD PROJECTS! Baleeted.
Chandler
Didn’t I say I’d be back? Ok, so the app is complicated, but the site is so well laid out. There are even videos and a very thorough Getting Started guide! How handy is that? Let me answer for you. Very handy. Good answer! So how easy is it to setup?
The answer to that apparently depends on your existing system. Their Get Started guide has a wealth of info on importing calendars, tasks, emails, notes, and data from all sorts of sources. That’s tremendous. If, on the other hand, you’re a disorganized slob like me, well, you can’t very well import from the pieces of paper you’ve just written, so you’re essentially on your own. I was unable to find documentation for the quick entry bar, and there’s no advertised shortcut to access that blank anyhow.
At least it hasn’t crashed yet.
[time passes]
Chandler does not have projects. Furthermore, it lacks any possibility for creating sub-tasks. What it does have are Collections, which are displayed vertically in the left-most pane. The defaults are already created for you: Work, Home, Fun.
If my life consisted solely of single things that needed to be done, and none of my tasks involved more than one or two steps to complete, this would be BRILLIANT. Just for one example, though, I need to update my contacts. This is a fairly simple, straightforward process that determines taking all of my contacts, updating them to contain current info, and then collecting them all into one place and propagating that information back to any other sources that need it.
How do I enter this in Chandler? Do I create one item that says “update contacts” and then put notes in it that say “Sync phone contacts via bluetooth. Sync Palm contacts via USB. Export Gmail contacts. Clean up data and import individually into existing contacts spreadsheet. Remove duplication. Sort through emails for any updates. Contact friends individually if I know there is more current info… oh wait, you’re bored reading this.
No, that’s not going to work. What other options are there? Decide all the next actions and enter them as separate Notes in chandler? No, because there’s no structure or order to that. So I do instead just enter the Very next action, and then when that’s finished, determine what the next Next action is and add that? You know what?
BALEETED.
Conclusion: If you want a good GTD solution, don’t be such a cheapskate!
Note: I haven’t tried ThinkingRock because I absolutely abhor java apps, so it’s automatically excluded. I have read that it’s brilliant. Nothing personal. Cheers, mate.
